Paris Court Voids Sotheby’s 2024 Sale of Pissarro Painting, Orders Return to Heirs and Buyer ID

·

A Paris court has voided Sotheby’s 2024 sale of a Camille Pissarro painting, ordered the work returned to the heirs of its prewar owner and, in an unusual step, told the auction house to identify the anonymous buyer within two months or face a penalty of 1,000 euros a day.

The Nov. 5 ruling by the Paris Judicial Court centered on Pissarro’s 1902 painting “Darse de pêche et bassin Duquesne, Dieppe, après-midi ensoleillée,” also known as “Le port de Dieppe.” Sotheby’s sold it on June 25, 2024, in London for 1.2 million pounds, about $1.6 million, in its Modern & Contemporary Evening Auction. The suit was brought by seven descendants of Salomon Flavian, identified in coverage as a Jewish banker, and the court found the painting had been seized in occupied Paris in 1941.

According to the judgment, Flavian bought the work at Hôtel Drouot in Paris on March 20, 1935. The court found that crates containing the painting were seized by German forces in 1941. It also pointed to the painting’s inclusion in France’s 1947 Répertoire des biens spoliés, the government register of looted property. Sotheby’s own 2024 catalog referenced that listing.

The dispute turned in part on a settlement described in the auction catalog. Sotheby’s said the work was being offered for sale “pursuant to a settlement between the current owner and heirs of Salomon Flavian.” Reporting said that agreement was brokered by Mondex Corp., a Toronto-based restitution firm. But the plaintiffs argued that only two relatives signed the settlement and that the other heirs were not consulted.

Sotheby’s and Mondex said provenance research showed the painting had left Flavian’s possession before World War II, pointing to a claimed chain through dealer Paul Rosenberg and later owner Edward Le Bas. The Paris court rejected that account, saying there was “no direct and convincing evidence” of a prewar sale and instead found support for wartime spoliation. It declared the 1941 dispossession and later sales null and void.

“It is a very important ruling, which opens the way to a restitution that the Flavian family has demanded since the war,” Corinne Hershkovitch, a lawyer for the claimants, told The Art Newspaper.

Mondex said it would appeal. “We are confident that when the vast amount of complex provenance research evidence is properly understood and considered that the court of appeal will reach a different conclusion,” James Palmer of Mondex said, according to ARTnews.

Sotheby’s said it welcomed the dismissal of charges against the auction house but was disappointed by the restitution ruling. It said it was reviewing the judgment and considering whether to join an appeal. The buyer-identification order cuts against the auction trade’s usual confidentiality practices; Sotheby’s has said client confidentiality is of paramount importance.

The ruling matters not just because it orders restitution, but because it couples that remedy with forced transparency. Auction houses typically do not disclose buyers publicly, and the court ordered Sotheby’s to provide the purchaser’s full identity to the claimants within two months.

The judgment was made immediately effective under French law, which courts can still use in Nazi-era restitution cases to nullify acts of spoliation and restore works to victims or their heirs. Still, because the sale took place in London, further legal steps will be needed to enforce the ruling in the United Kingdom. For now, the clearest deadline is the one imposed on Sotheby’s: identify the buyer within two months or begin incurring the daily fine.

Tags: #art, #restitution, #sothebys, #lootedart