ArXiv preprint claims possible 0.38‑parsec binary supermassive black holes in NGC 5044

A new arXiv preprint reports what could be the smallest directly resolved pair of active supermassive black holes yet seen: two radio-bright cores just 0.38 parsec apart in NGC 5044, a nearby giant elliptical galaxy at the center of the NGC 5044 group. If the interpretation holds up, the result would mark a rare direct view of a binary black hole system at an exceptionally tight separation.

The caveat is important. The paper, “Direct imaging of sub-parsec binary SMBHs in the central galaxy of the NGC 5044 group,” was posted to arXiv on Sept. 18 and is listed as under review at Nature Communications. It has not been peer reviewed. Even so, the claim is drawing attention because it targets a stage of black hole pairing that astronomers have struggled to observe directly.

The study was led by Francesco Ubertosi of the University of Bologna and INAF-IRA, with co-authors including researchers at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics and the Naval Research Laboratory. The team used the Very Long Baseline Array, a continent-scale radio telescope network built to resolve structures just milliarcseconds across, to observe NGC 5044 at 4.9, 8.4, 15.2 and 23.6 GHz over multiple epochs from 2020 to 2026.

In those data, the galaxy’s nuclear radio emission splits into two compact components, labeled C1 and C2. After correcting for mild frequency-dependent “core shift” effects, the authors measured a projected separation of 2.52 plus or minus 0.10 milliarcseconds, equivalent to 0.38 plus or minus 0.02 parsec at the paper’s adopted distance of 31.2 megaparsecs.

The authors say both sources look like active galactic nucleus cores, not one core plus a blob in a jet. In the abstract, they write: “The 4.9, 8.4, 15.2, and 23.6 GHz VLBA images reveal two compact, flat-spectrum, and variable radio cores separated by just 0.38 parsec at the heart of the galaxy, forming the tightest directly imaged binary AGN known by an order of magnitude.” In radio astronomy, a flat-to-inverted spectrum and flux variability are both common signs of an accreting black hole core. The team argues those traits, together with the components’ compact appearance and positions, make C2 unlikely to be a jet knot from the primary source.

That matters because securely confirmed binary active galactic nuclei are uncommon, especially at small separations. The paper says only a handful have been confirmed at distances of a few hundred parsecs, and only one previously confirmed parsec-scale binary had been securely and visually identified before this claim: 4C+37.11, also known as 0402+379, with a projected separation of about 7.3 parsecs. A system at 0.38 parsec would move the direct imaging record far inward, toward the stage where the two black holes are expected to interact more strongly and edge closer to merger.

The paper cites earlier work putting the total black hole mass in NGC 5044 at roughly 2 billion times the mass of the sun. Systems in this regime are of particular interest to pulsar timing arrays, which search for nanohertz gravitational waves by tracking tiny timing changes in rapidly spinning neutron stars. Sub-parsec supermassive black hole binaries are among the kinds of objects expected to contribute to that low-frequency signal.

The authors also suggest the galaxy’s older radio outbursts may have come from the secondary core rather than requiring the main jet axis to have swung to a new direction. As the abstract puts it, “This discovery suggests that the older outbursts may have been powered by jets from the secondary core, without invoking any reorientation of the primary jet axis.”

For now, though, the headline claim remains provisional. Direct imaging of black hole pairs at such small scales is difficult, and some past smaller-separation claims have not survived follow-up scrutiny. NGC 5044 may represent a major observational milestone, but that will depend on peer review and independent confirmation.