U.N. Third Committee Rejects U.S. Attempts to Narrow Women’s Rights, ICC Language; Resolutions Head to Full Assembly
U.N. member states at the General Assembly’s human rights committee rejected a series of U.S. attempts this week to narrow the language of several resolutions on women’s rights, sexual orientation and gender identity, and the International Criminal Court, then adopted the texts anyway. The votes at the General Assembly’s Third Committee underscored a basic reality of that forum: Washington can push for changes, but it cannot block a resolution on its own.
The clearest fights came over three issues. In resolutions on violence against women and girls and on trafficking in women and girls, the United States sought to qualify references to sexual and reproductive rights by adding the phrase “in accordance with national laws.” Russia, meanwhile, tried to delete a reference to the International Criminal Court from the trafficking resolution. Egypt sought to remove the phrase “sexual orientation and gender identity” from a separate resolution on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions.
Those efforts failed in the Third Committee’s mid-November meetings during the General Assembly’s 81st session, according to U.N. meeting records from Nov. 13-18. The committee went on to adopt the resolutions with the disputed language intact, including the draft on “Intensification of efforts to prevent and eliminate all forms of violence against women and girls,” which it considered around Nov. 17. The texts now move to the full General Assembly, where final adoption is typically expected in December.
The United States also broke with past practice on several other human rights texts. It voted against a resolution on human rights defenders after objecting to language on gender and reproductive rights. It also abstained on resolutions it had traditionally supported, including those on North Korea, Myanmar and Ukrainian territories occupied by Russia, citing objections to references to the ICC. On the North Korea human rights resolution, the committee vote on Nov. 18 was 95 in favor, 14 against and 58 abstentions.
The Third Committee is the General Assembly’s main forum for negotiating human rights resolutions. Those measures are nonbinding, meaning they do not carry the force of law, but they matter politically because they shape diplomatic norms, U.N. programming and the terms governments are willing to accept in multilateral negotiations. And unlike the U.N. Security Council, where the five permanent members hold veto power, neither the General Assembly nor its committees allow any one country to stop a text on its own.
That procedural reality is central to what happened this week. The United States pressed for narrower wording on sexual and reproductive rights and opposed ICC references, but other member states did not accept those changes. Russia and Egypt likewise failed to win support for their proposed deletions. The result was not just a symbolic disagreement: the committee advanced the resolutions with the contested language preserved.
Washington’s position on the ICC helps explain why court references became a flashpoint across multiple votes. The United States is not a party to the Rome Statute, the treaty that created the court, and under President Donald Trump’s administration it has taken a sharply hostile line toward the ICC in U.N. negotiations. In an explanation of vote cited in Third Committee proceedings, the U.S. said it “strongly supports” the resolution on protecting women and girls but “disassociates from references to the International Criminal Court.”
The episode was highlighted Friday in a dispatch from Human Rights Watch, but the core record comes from the U.N. committee’s own transcripts and meeting summaries. For now, the diplomatic bottom line is straightforward: the U.S. sought to rewrite a cluster of human rights texts at the United Nations, member states refused, and the resolutions are heading to the full General Assembly largely unchanged.