CFTC Files Civil Fraud Suit Accusing Backward Hat of $550M Ponzi; DOJ Unseals Criminal Charges, Arrests Two
The U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission on Friday said it filed a civil fraud case in federal court in Indiana accusing Phillip Williams, Devin Johnson and 11 Backward Hat-related entities of running a Ponzi scheme that took in more than $550 million from at least 2,100 participants. In a significant early step for potential victims, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana has already entered a restraining order freezing assets, allowing the CFTC to inspect records and appointing Kevin B. Duff as temporary receiver to take control of the defendant companies and certain assets.
The civil case comes two days after federal prosecutors in Manhattan unsealed a criminal complaint charging Williams and Johnson with securities fraud and wire fraud tied to Backward Hat Capital. The Justice Department said authorities arrested Williams in Kokomo, Indiana, and Johnson in Gilbert, Arizona, underscoring that the matter is now moving forward as a parallel criminal and civil enforcement action involving multiple agencies.
According to the unsealed criminal complaint, Backward Hat marketed private fund-style investments tied to foreign-exchange trading, or forex, telling investors it used a “proprietary” algorithm to exploit arbitrage opportunities. Investors were shown monthly returns typically above 6%, a pace that would amount to more than 100% annually if sustained.
Prosecutors allege those returns were largely illusory and that management set the reported rates internally rather than generating them through trading performance. They also allege Backward Hat used more than $200 million in incoming investor money to pay redemption requests from earlier investors — a hallmark of a Ponzi scheme — while transferring “hundreds of millions” to insiders, including more than $130 million to Williams and more than $40 million to Johnson.
By the summer of 2026, prosecutors allege, the firm was struggling to meet withdrawal requests. Investor communications in October blamed banking, crypto-transfer or identity-verification problems, but prosecutors say the real issue was that assets had been depleted. The CFTC said the solicitation of funds continued at least through October 2026.
The two cases describe the alleged scheme at slightly different scale, and both figures come from the agencies’ own filings. The CFTC said the operation received more than $550 million from at least 2,100 participants. The U.S. attorney’s office in the Southern District of New York said the scheme raised more than $600 million from over 2,000 investors.
The CFTC named what it called the “Backward Hat Common Enterprise,” including entities such as Backward Hat Capital Fund LP, Backward Hat Group LLC and Backward Hat Capital Management LLC. The agency said it is seeking restitution for investors, disgorgement of ill-gotten gains, civil monetary penalties, trading and registration bans, and a permanent injunction.
The regulator, which oversees U.S. derivatives markets, said the SEC also filed a related civil action and sought an emergency restraining order. The FBI’s Indianapolis Field Office is seeking potential victims and directed investors to contact [email protected] or use the bureau’s online victim-information form.
“This action reflects the CFTC’s continuing commitment to policing fraud, including ongoing schemes, and securing assets for victims,” David I. Miller, the agency’s enforcement director, said in a statement.
For investors, the immediate practical development is the court’s order preserving what assets may remain. With a freeze in place and a court-appointed receiver now controlling the companies and certain property, the case has moved beyond allegations alone and into the stage where authorities are trying to keep funds from disappearing while the parallel fraud cases proceed.